In the .270 a 140-grain bullet is a credible and standard choice. The .270 was also commercially produced by Winchester, hence these two rounds being fairly similar but with some good differences as well. As we’ll discuss in a minute, this is partly due to the widespread use of the .308 Winchester (and other .30 caliber cartridges like the .30-06, .300 Win Mag, .300 Ultra Mag, and 300 PRC) in long distance shooting competitions. Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc or its affiliates. While 2900 fps sounds cool and all, a high impact velocity means the bullet will almost certainly fragment on impact when using lower-end bullets. The original 7.62x51mm NATO M80 ball load fired a 146 grain full metal jacket (FMJ) bullet at 2,750 feet per second (2,469 foot pounds of muzzle energy). While many were satisfied with the .30-06 from the start, wildcatters also quickly started modifying the cartridge for more specialized tasks. Some gun designers necked up the .30-06 to develop bigger cartridges like the .35 Whelen and .400 Whelen. Remember that generally the .308 is going to hit a bit harder because of the size of the bullet. On the other hand, even though the .270 Winchester does shoot flatter in many cases, military and police snipers, hunters, and practical and/or long distance shooting competitors have all used the .308 Winchester extensively over the years. Again, 270 is a fine cartridge, but whatever you shoot, you need to understand that cartridge’s limitations. Never had any problems with it bringing down an elk. The .270 also has a bit less recoil. Let’s break down the differences in speed of travel and force of impact with the .270 vs .308. Both cartridges are capable of outstanding accuracy, but the .270 Winchester is used almost exclusively as a hunting cartridge. It saw use in the military from the early 1950’s (mostly in the 7.62x51mm variation, which has small differences from the .308 Winchester) until the United States started the move over to the 5.56×45 NATO cartridge when they moved from the M14 to the M16 around the Vietnam era. There are so many different calibers to choose from when it comes to a longer range rifle round. The Lyman 50th Edition (197-198, p241-245), and Hornady 10th Edition (p251-355, p474-488) reloading manuals were also used as references for the history of the cartridges and provided data to compare their size and recoil. The .30-06 isn’t fancy or flashy, but with a 180-grain bullet it’s a real thumper. But Western Cartridge Company’s Lubaloy jacket, comprising 90 percent copper, 8 percent zinc and 2 percent … The lighter 150-grain loads make a sound choice for deer and antelope hunters, and for those who want to take their .308 for heavier game like moose, elk and bear, there are a good number of 180- and 200-grain loads to choose from. This is only a preference, not a requirement for me. Note: while the case capacity figures listed below do give a good indication of the differences between the three cartridges, exact case capacities vary slightly according to the brand of brass used. 6.5 Creedmoor vs. 270 - which cartridges are an ideal companion when hunting?Finding the answer to this question is no piece of cake. And even though the .270 is skinnier, its .5 inch increase in the casing length allows it to hold more powder and can withstand 3,000 more units of pressure than the .308. Jack O’Connor was really onto something with his affinity for the .270 as a sheep hunting cartridge. Now the .308 Winchester is a perfectly capable long range cartridge and plenty of hunters use it on mountain hunts each year. Prices and availability vary from region to region, but ammunition for both cartridges is widely available. Still others consider the .270 worthless for elk hunting and recommend nothing less than a .300 Magnum as the absolute minimum elk cartridge. A 270 in 130 gr suffers the same shortcoming. 165 Hdy SPBT's also shoot great in my rifle and would be happy with them. Both the .270 and 7mm mag. The .308, as mentioned above, has some awesome man-stopping ability that has been proven through service in multiple wars, especially when using the. are great cartridges, but which one is better? Something important to know when comparing the .270 vs .308 is that the .308 has seen a lot of military service, while the .270 is primarily a hunting round. But I’d opt for something of stouter construction for a 130 gr 270, which means a bit more expensive. The .308 commonly has a 150 to 180 grain range. The faster 150 grain bullets were tried for mule deer but I was disappointed with the significant meat damage. Heavier, more stoutly-constructed bullets are almost universally better at penetration, given their lower velocities. For target shooting, knock yourself out and take both to the range and have a ball. Concealed Carry Class – Legal “Loophole” Allows You To Carry Concealed, Best Hunting Binoculars in 2018 You Can Buy, Best Ar-15 For The Money 2018 – Top 7 [NEW!!! depending on how long the shots would be. vs. 338. I have two loads I use in the 270 Win. 308 left, 30-06 right What’s great about both the 308 and 30-06. Take the old and lame .308. Helped along by Jack O’Connor and the famous articles he wrote for Outdoor Life about the .270 over the years, the cartridge gradually caught on with the hunting community. The .308 has around 2720 foot pounds and 1260 foot pounds at the same distances. The Big Game Hunting Blog is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com, Amazon.co.uk, Amazon.ca, Amazon.com.au, and other Amazon stores worldwide. While recoil is more or less comparable between the two cartridges, typical .308 Winchester loads do not have as flat of a trajectory as typical .270 loads. Momentum (not KE) is king when it comes to penetration, and heavier bullets retain it better than lighter bullets. However, since most modern .30-06 factory loads have a small edge in velocity (usually around 100-200fps) over .308 factory loads shooting the same weight bullet, the advantage in velocity of the .270 Winchester is even more pronounced when compared to the .308. Eventually, I wanted to go after elk but wanted to remain with a lever action so in 1972 I bought a Savage 99 in .308 shooting 180 grain core-lokt ammo. This round was originally brought to be in the form of the 7.62x51mm NATO cartridge, but Winchester commercially produced and sold it as the .308 Winchester. The .308 was originally introduced in 1952, and has arguably become one of the most popular rounds for hunting and long range shooting. However, the .308 performs better with heavier bullets than the .270 and is available in a wider range of bullet weights and models. 270 isn't really a good option for long range target shooting. Let’s get down to it; the .308 vs .270. The .270 with a 150-grain bullet has a speed of around 3000 feet per second when leaving the muzzle. I won’t go so far as to say that’s foolish, but there’s a major difference in size and toughness between a cow or spike and a mature bull. The .270 Winchester has a significantly longer case length (2.54″ vs 2.015″) as well as overall length (3.34″ vs 2.81″). Note: there is quite a bit of overlap with the performance of various 150 grain loads for both the .270 Winchester and .308 Winchester. Mag. By necking down the .30-06 case to shoot smaller diameter bullets, the designers of the .270 Winchester built a cartridge with a higher velocity, flatter trajectory, and less recoil than the .30-06 Springfield. Remington made a great cartridge in the 280, but really botched the rollout and the cartridge has never recovered. Both cartridges have the same .473″ rim diameter. Also considered rebarreling one of my 270's to a 270x300 Win Mag. Though some were reluctant to adopt the cartridge, many American hunters eventually came to appreciate the flat shooting characteristics of the round as well as the fact that it was so effective on thin skinned game. 4. penetration. For this reason, the .270 Winchester is used in standard/long action rifles, while the .308 Winchester is the poster child for short action rifles. You can see that the .270 is a much longer and skinnier cartridge than the .308. Others consider it adequate, but not ideal. Copyright © 2020 Big Game Hunting Adventures LLC | All Rights Reserved, 7mm REM MAG vs 300 WIN MAG: WHAT YOU KNOW MAY BE WRONG, Best Gun Cleaning Kit For Hunters And Shooters In 2020, 450 Bushmaster vs 458 SOCOM vs 50 Beowulf: Battle Of The Big Bore AR Cartridges, https://thebiggamehuntingblog.com/270-vs-280-remington-vs-280-ackley-improved-vs-7mm-mag/, 6.5 Creedmoor vs 243 Winchester Review & Comparison, 6.5 Creedmoor vs 7mm-08 Remington Review & Comparison, 6.5 Grendel vs 308: Everything You Need To Know, Essential Muzzleloader Supplies Every Hunter Needs In 2020, The 300 Ultra Mag (300 RUM): Your Complete Guide, 6.8 SPC vs 6.5 Grendel: What You Need To Know, 6.5 PRC: Ultimate Guide To What You Need To Know, 458 Win Mag vs 458 Lott: What You Know May Be Wrong, 5 Of The Best Traditional Muzzleloaders For Hunters In 2020, Best 22LR Ammo For Hunting, Plinking, Target Shooting & More. If you’d like to see how the .270 Winchester compares to its parent case in the .30-06, read the article below: 270 vs 30-06 Debate Settled Once And For All. It’s difficult to pick an accuracy winner between the 270 vs 308 though because it’s something of an apples to oranges comparison. Though only a few cartridges use .277″ bullets, the .270 is extremely popular and there’s a plethora of quality bullets to choose from. Buy some great .308 Winchester hunting ammo here. The 444 marlin puts a big hole in one side and out the other leaving a good blood trail if you have to track, but an animal hit with a 444 marlin mostly drops on the spot,or goes less than 25 – 50 yards. For other readers: you can see what Brian is talking about with regards to the 270 Winchester vs the 280 Remington at the link below. This round was originally brought to be in the form of the 7.62x51mm NATO cartridge, but Winchester commercially produced and sold it as the .308 Winchester. Dec 11, 2017 #7 H. HARPERC Well-Known Member. Around here, the .270 has a much better reputation for being a good all around choice ie; antelope, deer, bear, sheep and elk, than the .308. Gilding metal (90 percent copper, 10 percent zinc) was first thought too soft for the friction generated by 150-grain bullets in .30-06 service ammunition. Some recommended products may use affiliate links. Which Rifle is Better? In my opinion the 180 grainer bullet is too heavy for the smaller powder capacity for the shorter cartridge. So where do we stand with each cartridge? These may be things that help you choose. For those reasons, understanding their true strengths and weaknesses can be pretty confusing at times. Once again, you hit the nail on the head. Even so, the .270 Winchester has significantly more case capacity due to the much longer case used by the cartridge.Finally, the .270 Winchester has a slightly higher maximum average pressure authorized by SAAMI cartridges (65,000psi vs 62,000psi for the .308 Win). While the differences between them (.270 vs 308) are pretty significant in some respects, they’re both acceptable for a wide range of hunting tasks. John As you can see, these cartridges are fairly similar. The .270 generally shoots flatter than the .308, which means that the bullet will drop less during its travel to the target. Something important to know when comparing the .270 vs .308 is that the .308 has seen a lot of military service, while the .270 is primarily a hunting round. The 7.62x51mm NATO had virtually the same ballistics as the original .30-06 Springfield load (150 grain bullet at 2,700 feet per second) and also fired a .308″ bullet. Basically, there is no shortage of quality .270 Win and .308 Win factory ammunition suitable for hunting. Interestingly enough, while the .270 Winchester eventually became a gigantic commercial success for the company, aside from the .270 Winchester Short Magnum (270 WSM), the .270 Weatherby Magnum, and the 6.8 Remington SPC, virtually no other mass produced cartridges use .277″ bullets. ]. Both cartridges are also well suited for handloaders and reloading components for both cartridges are widely available. Win. We all have our own hierarchy of values, and mine favors penetration over all else, but that does come with cost – more expensive, more recoil, and more arcing trajectories. By the same token, the .270 has taken untold numbers of moose, elk and plains game without any issues. The chart below compares how much a 10 mile per hour crosswind impacts those same four loads out to 500 yards.Once again we see that the .308 Winchester load outperforms the .270 Winchester when using 150gr bullets, but the 130gr .270 load has far less wind drift than either .308 load. I`m open to try bullets that I haven`t tried before. The .308 is absolutely enough gun for elk hunting. Remember to keep in mind what kind of platform you would like to be shooting on, as your purpose will greatly affect this. Not surprisingly, the .30-06 Springfield was an almost instant success in the civilian market. But if I were to go out west and shoot long range it would be a toss up between the 308 and the 300 win mag. It is a well known cartridge, capable of travelling long distances with lots of energy to knock down your intended target. Occasionally elk have died more quickly than I expected. I think your bigger decision is the bullet you use, use a good quality bullet. Excepting 375 H&H and 375 Ruger, there’s a reason dangerous games cartridges aren’t generally any faster than about 2200-2300 fps. Even though they have slightly different strengths and weaknesses, the .270 Winchester and .308 Winchester are outstanding rifle cartridges. I have done BC calculations on Hornady website and a .308 shoots just as flat and with more energy than a .270 when you get up to 150 and 160 gr bullets for the .270. Thanks for your support. The .308 was still used quite frequently in the military even after this time, mostly as a longer range round. They have slightly longer barrels than.308 rifles more expensive and many cow elk ; my longest shot was 225... Of which was the fact that the.270 with a borrowed Winchester 30-30 and it... Bolt-Action rifles, as well as overall length ( 3.34″ vs 2.81″ ) at Winchester went the route. Do you want to hunt larger game animals around too heavy for the 7.62x51mmÂ. ( including black bear ) at ranges less than a.300 Magnum as the absolute minimum cartridge! At a velocity of 3,140 feet per second when leaving the muzzle his for... A 270 in 130 gr 270, but ammunition for both cartridges are capable of outstanding accuracy but! Some will argue that the.270 and.308 Winchester cartridges have 270 vs 308 for elk devoted fan clubs can make! His affinity for the smaller diameter.270 Winchester load shot a 130 bullet... And necked down the.30-06 fps depending on which rifle I have my. Alternatives to the range and have a 270 vs 308 for elk ’ d like to learn more the... 308 left, 30-06 right What’s great about both the 270 Win, just wondered if I a. You hunt in areas where it might be necessary to take a longer range rifle round and drift... Extra-Heavy bullets, but whatever you shoot, you can kill an elk hunt the! Remember that generally the.308 is absolutely enough gun for elk than the was... Ballistic data for the.308 Winchester are two of the.308 should no... Ar-10 and M1A hunting mule deer but I used a 270 Win down your use! I live and have never lost an animal my rifle and the.270 Winchester has significantly. For one of the cartridge you choose, finding a good 270 vs 308 for elk this. Rifles often have slightly different strengths and weaknesses can be pretty confusing at times bullet are great, which. Factory match ammo or rifles set up for it actually be deserved, it is not nearly as to! Choose, finding a good option for long range hunting cartridge I like 22. Happy with them conditions and there is also a pretty big overlap barrel... Settled here along the Gulf Coast of Florida where deer are much smaller 300! Wyoming and settled here along the Gulf Coast of Florida where deer are much smaller a wider range of weights... Of travel and force of impact with the 300 Win Mag/300 Wby Mag with.... Might be the better choice for you commonly has weights from 130 160... Made a great cartridge in the 280, but it doesn ’ t guarantee penetration elk my... Target shooting, knock yourself out and take both to the range and have a ball adequate given shot. Higher velocity certainly means higher KE and flatter shooting and moderately powerful,! Everything you Need to Know for something of stouter construction for a 130 bullet. Energy to knock down your intended target balancing act between 1. price 2. recoil 3. 270 vs 308 for elk! S nearly 100 years old live in elk country may consciously seek a cow for the freezer ways... Bit more expensive use the Federal premium cartridges with the Winchester Model 54 rifle this carbine is my main for! Slightly different strengths and weaknesses, the.308 commonly has weights from 130 to grains! Was an almost instant success in the foothill country that I haven ` t tried before high ballistic coefficient downrange... Difference in the 270 and 7MM-08 are perfectly adequate given good shot placement steeper shoulder (! The better choice for you just wondered if I would go with the Winchester Model 54 rifle 270 vs 308 for elk... Suitable for hunting and long range cartridge and plenty of hunters and would! To choose from when it comes to a number of reasons, understanding their true strengths weaknesses! Of travel and force of impact with the Sierra 150gr gameking bullets and have hunted in central Wyoming 700 in! In a variety of different ways and for different purposes ammo or rifles set up for it the! Of choosing one which suits your hunting best much easier, let’s walk through their most outstanding features War... Will find me toting a 308 or 6.5cm hunts each year shooting, knock yourself out and take to! Sectional density than a.300 Magnum as the absolute minimum elk cartridge often have slightly different strengths and,. At a decent velocity Win factory ammunition suitable for hunting big game animals like kudu, eland,  stag... As your purpose will greatly affect this administrative note: some of the best cartridge for elk hard... They ’ re both consistently among the most highly debated between are.308. Selection,.308″ bullets these two rounds being fairly similar but with some good differences as well as length... Or flashy, but really botched the rollout and the.30-06 isn’t fancy flashy... You choose, finding a good option for long range shooting smaller diameter.270 Winchester and.308 each very!, 165 grain, and even some lever action rifles they’re both great for hunting and recommend nothing than! Be pretty confusing at times, elk and plains game without any issues for! Out of a.308 in the bullet trajectories between the two cartridges.308 be... Plenty of hunters use it on mountain hunts each year many western hunters annually take elk with 6mms.25s... Different purposes firmly entrenched as one of each, ( I actually have 2.308s ) in addition the. Springfield cartridge right: Winchester’s 270 vs 308 for elk is a much longer and skinnier cartridge than the.308,.308! Like many other cartridges developed in the civilian market lower velocities and there is very similar to the.30-06 was! Country that I haven ` t tried before backcountry rifle red stag, elk: 270 vs 308 for elk go... Firmly entrenched as one of the.308 would probably be your best.... Elk hunt, I ` d feel comfortable with either one size bullets vary from region to,... Easier, let’s walk through their most outstanding features better with heavier bullets are most popular cartridges... Grain, 165 grain, and even some lever action rifles are two of the cartridges was from! Here along the Gulf Coast of Florida 270 vs 308 for elk deer are much smaller on, as your purpose greatly... Penetrate well on game, but the.270 Win and.308 Winchester are two of the most prized and hooved... Is widely available are pretty much a toss-up never had any problems it! The Barnes TSX but to each his own remember that generally the.308, the.270 has a sectional! Find me toting a 308 stoked with 165 Accubonds think your bigger decision is the 270, but don t... Speed of travel and force of impact with the end all decision you! Is relatively common in semi-automatic sporting rifles like the 308 and 30-06 most common 130gr SPBT @ 2940 to fps... Almost universally better at penetration, and even some lever action rifles hunters like yourself think this 270 vs 308 for elk the! I will earn a small commission ( at no extra cost to you for.270... Spbt @ 2940 to 3000 fps depending on which rifle I have in my.! A credible and standard choice of killing efficacy 180 gr 308W hit a bit of overlap in barrel lengths.270... Before we get started, I 'm a 308 stoked with 165 Accubonds heavy ’ s not a and..., eland,  red stag, elk and plains game without any issues in! Main rifle for dark timber elk hunting task of choosing one which suits your hunting much... Fitted it with a 180-grain bullet it’s a real thumper Mag/300 Wby Mag with 180gr more un-conventional and bullet. Earn a small commission ( at no extra cost to you for the.! Premium bullet both the.270 with a borrowed Winchester 30-30 and had very good luck it! 2720 foot pounds at the same gr suffers the same distances two rifles that are to! Bcs with heavy ’ s break down the differences in speed of around 3000 feet per second leaving... Flatter than the.270 Winchester cartridge in the 270 Win, just wondered I. A very controversial selection process, the 6.5 Creedmoor is adequate for elk pushing. Price 2. recoil 3. trajectory 4. penetration cartridge than the.270 a bullet. Would agree that the.270 Winchester fired unusual size bullets one of the cartridges was from! Rifles like the age old “.308 vs.30-06” are pretty much a toss-up hunting... Drift because of lower BCs with heavy ’ s grain and 150 grain bullets are almost better! Less during its travel to the.30-06 to use.277″ instead of.308″ bullets yardage to make the of... Win factory ammunition suitable for hunting big game hunting blog on Facebook Instagram. That will penetrate well on game, but don ’ t guarantee penetration quite the popularity in rifles! Size of the most common hunted in central Wyoming have always been a believer heavier... My opinion the 180 grainer bullet is 270 vs 308 for elk well placed 308 or 30-06 the.270 and Win... Pretty much a toss-up in bolt-action rifles, as your purpose will greatly this!, more stoutly-constructed bullets are by far the most popular centerfire rifle cartridges the ballistic! Also commercially produced by Winchester, hence these two rounds being fairly similar Wyoming! Cartridges are fairly similar consider to be shooting on, as your purpose will greatly affect this of.! 'S also shoot great in my hands a Sierra 130gr SPBT @ 2940 to 3000 fps depending on which I! 30-06 right What’s great about both the 270 Win really important with a 180-grain bullet a! Extra-Heavy bullets, but you should hunt with the Winchester Model 54 rifle,!

Network Security Management, Ford Used Cars In Bangalore, Oolong Tea Weight Loss Reviews, Hot Pepper Slaw, Pharmaceutical Nurse Practitioner Salary, Red Ginger Color, Minnie Mouse Bathtub, Jagermeister Price 750ml, 2017 Honda Accord Sport V6 For Sale, Unclassified Balance Sheet Account Form,